Universidad Complutense de Madrid
E-Prints Complutense

What do Experts Know About Ranking Journal Quality? A Comparison with ISI Research Impact in Finance

Impacto

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year



Chang, Chia-Lin and McAleer, Michael (2012) What do Experts Know About Ranking Journal Quality? A Comparison with ISI Research Impact in Finance. [ Documentos de Trabajo del Instituto Complutense de Análisis Económico (ICAE); nº 01, 2012, ] (Submitted)

[img]
Preview
PDF
Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial.

405kB

Official URL: http://eprints.ucm.es/14091/


URLURL Type
https://www.ucm.es/icaeOrganisation


Abstract

Experts possess knowledge and information that are not publicly available. The paper is concerned with the ranking of academic journal quality and research impact using a survey of experts from a national project on ranking academic finance journals. A comparison is made with publicly available bibliometric data, namely the Thomson Reuters ISI Web of Science citations database (hereafter ISI) for the Business - Finance category. The paper analyses the leading international journals in Finance using expert scores and quantifiable Research Assessment Measures (RAMs), and highlights the similarities and differences in the expert scores and alternative RAMs, where the RAMs are based on alternative transformations of citations taken from the ISI database. Alternative RAMs may be calculated annually or updated daily to answer the perennial questions as to When, Where and How (frequently) published papers are cited (see Chang et al. (2011a, b, c)). The RAMs include the most widely used RAM, namely the classic 2-year impact factor including journal self citations (2YIF), 2-year impact factor excluding journal self citations (2YIF*), 5-year impact factor including journal self citations (5YIF), Immediacy (or zero-year impact factor (0YIF)), Eigenfactor, Article Influence, C3PO (Citation Performance Per Paper Online), h-index, PI-BETA (Papers Ignored - By Even The Authors), 2-year Self-citation Threshold Approval Ratings (2Y-STAR), Historical Self-citation Threshold Approval Ratings (H-STAR), Impact Factor Inflation (IFI), and Cited Article Influence (CAI). As data are not available for 5YIF, Article Influence and CAI for 13 of the leading 34 journals considered, 10 RAMs are analysed for 21 highly-cited journals in Finance. Harmonic mean rankings of the 10 RAMs for the 34 highly-cited journals are also presented. It is shown that emphasizing the 2-year impact factor of a journal, which partly answers the question as to When published papers are cited, to the exclusion of other informative RAMs, which answer Where and How (frequently) published papers are cited, can lead to a distorted evaluation of journal impact and influence relative to the Harmonic Mean rankings. A simple regression model is used to predict expert scores on the basis of RAMs that capture journal impact, journal policy, the number of high quality papers, and quantitative information about a journal.


Item Type:Working Paper or Technical Report
Additional Information:

The authors are grateful to Shing-yang Hu (National Taiwan University) for providing the data on Expert Scores. For financial support, the first author wishes to thank the National Science Council, Taiwan, and the second author wishes to acknowledge the Australian Research Council, National Science Council, Taiwan, and the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science.

Uncontrolled Keywords:Expert scores, Journal quality, Research assessment measures, Impact factor, IFI, C3PO, PI-BETA, STAR, Eigenfactor, Article Influence, h-index.
Subjects:Social sciences > Economics > Finance
Social sciences > Library science and documentation > Databases
Social sciences > Economics > Econometrics
Social sciences > Library science and documentation > Information retrieval
Social sciences > Library science and documentation > Information management
JEL:C18, C81, C83
Series Name:Documentos de Trabajo del Instituto Complutense de Análisis Económico (ICAE)
Volume:2012
Number:01
ID Code:14091
Deposited On:10 Jan 2012 15:14
Last Modified:17 Jun 2016 09:29

Origin of downloads

Repository Staff Only: item control page