Fighting cheaters: How and how much to invest



Downloads per month over past year

Nuño, Juan Carlos and Herrero, Miguel A. and Primicerio, Mario (2010) Fighting cheaters: How and how much to invest. European Journal of Applied Mathematics, 21 (4-5). pp. 459-478. ISSN 0956-7925

[thumbnail of Herrero02.pdf] PDF

Official URL:


Human societies are formed by different socio-economical classes which are characterized by their contribution to, and their share of, the common wealth available. Cheaters, defined as those individuals that do not contribute to the common wealth but benefit from it, have always existed, and are likely to be present in all societies in the foreseeable future. Their existence brings about serious problems since they act as sinks for the community wealth and deplete resources which are always limited and often scarce. To fight cheaters, a society can invest additional resources to pursue one or several aims. For instance, an improvement in social solidarity (e.g. by fostering education) may be sought. Alternatively, deterrence (e.g. by increasing police budget) may be enhanced. Then the following questions naturally arise: (i) how much to spend and (ii) how to allocate the expenditure between both strategies above. This paper addresses this general issue in a simplified setting, which however we believe of some interest. More precisely, we consider a society constituted by two productive classes and an unproductive one, the cheaters, and proposes a dynamical system that describes their evolution in time. We find it convenient to formulate our model as a three-dimensional ordinary differential equation (ODE) system whose variables are the cheater population, the total wealth and one of the productive social classes. The stationary values of the cheater population and the total wealth are studied in terms of the two parameters: phi (how much to invest) and s (how to distribute such expenditure). We show that it is not possible to simultaneously minimize the cheater population and maximize the total wealth with respect to phi and s. We then discuss the possibility of defining a compromise function to find suitable values of phi and s that optimize the response to cheating. In our opinion, this qualitative approach may be of some help to plan and implement social strategies against cheating.

Item Type:Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:Public-goods; punishment; cooperation
Subjects:Sciences > Mathematics > Differential equations
Social sciences > Sociology > Social research
ID Code:17696
Deposited On:16 Jan 2013 09:51
Last Modified:14 Dec 2018 15:08

Origin of downloads

Repository Staff Only: item control page