Publication:
The influences of public law on private law and the correlations of the corporate social responsibility vs. the human rights

Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Full text at PDC
Publication Date
2015
Advisors (or tutors)
Editors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Citations
Google Scholar
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Abstract
Historically, the debate about the existing confrontation between Public and Private Law dates back to the middle twentieth century, primarily to the decision of the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany (FCCG) on the Lüth case of 1958. Since then, the discussion has been gaining some space, even being considered the “full Constitutionalization of Law” (Vergrundrechtlichung des gesamten Rechts), on one hand, and celebrated as the full accomplishment of the fundamental rights (Alexy, 2009)[1], on the other. With the conflict between these two legal spheres (Public and Private Law), the legal protection of the fundamental rights was extended beyond its subjectivist affirmation, where individual rights were only confronted with the State. However, from that moment on, fundamental rights are seen as a consequence of the formation of objective principles, both determiners of legislative measures and inspirers of the legal order. They meant, therefore, the application of Law to individuals and, furthermore, allowed for the interpretation of the precepts of the German Civil Code (BGB) in direct harmony with fundamental rights. The Drittwirkug (irradiation of precepts) was acknowledged. Fundamental rights got free from the unilateral orientation towards the governmental intervention of the time and became universally valid (Grimm, 2006)[2]. Therefore, one might raise the following question: “how would the entailment of private law be applied to fundamental rights?”. German author Canaris (2003) [3] provides us with some orientation: the fundamental rights stand immediately given the norms of private law (dominant opinion), and this perspective is adopted by the FCCG, which has been trialling with a strong control of proportionality and of prohibition of the excess in light of the norms of fundamental rights in confrontation with the norms of private law. In fact, how can we think the confrontation between the norms of Public Law and the ones of Private Law within Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) – which, eminently, are not controlled by the Judiciary? This question is currently debated from the perspective of the purpose of the CSR: the business ethics. On the other hand, human rights are consecrated on the international order and its application is unquestionable within companies. All companies must respect human rights of stakeholders. Hence, is there any entailment between the norms of Public Law (here, human rights) and the ones of CSR? This is the debate we intend to present at this conference.
Description
Keywords
Citation
[1] ALEXY, R. “Derechos Fundamentales y Estado Constitucional Democrático”, in: Neoconstitucionalismo(s), Editorial Trotta, Madrid, 4.ª ed., 2009. [2] GRIMM, D. Constitucionalismo y Derechos Fundamentales, Editorial Trotta: Madrid, 2006. [3] CANARIS, C.W. Direitos Fundamentais e Direito Privado, trad. Ingo Wolfgang Sarlet & Paulo Mota Pinto, Almedina, Coimbra, 2003.VEIGA, Fábio da Silva. “El gobierno de las sociedades y los derechos humanos de los stakeholders”, in: MIRANDA GONÇALVES, Rubén (Coord.). Derechos humanos y juventud, Santiago de Compostela: Xunta de Galicia, 2015. VEIGA, Fábio da Silva. “A responsabilidade tributária por violação dos deveres de administração”, in: Revista do Instituto do Direito Brasileiro, ano I, vol. 9, Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de Lisboa: Lisboa, 2012, p. 5753-5765. ISSN: 2182-7567. VEIGA, Fábio da Silva. “O interesse social: dos interesses dos shareholders aos interesses dos stakeholders”, in: Revista Âmbito Jurídico, n.º 102, ano XV, julho 2012, Rio Grande. ISSN: 1518-0360 VEIGA, Fábio da Silva; LARANJEIRA, Amanda Lúcia Araújo. “O dever de lealdade dos administradores: consequências no dever de não concorrência e não apropriação das oportunidades de negócios – sob a perspectiva do direito português”, in: Revista Âmbito Jurídico, XIV, n. 87, abril, Rio Grande, 2011. ISSN: 1518-0360. VEIGA, Fábio da Silva; LARANJEIRA, Amanda Lúcia Araújo. “Aspetos da posição dominante correlatos ao abuso de atos anticoncorrenciais no mercado europeu”, in: Revista do Instituto do Direito Brasileiro, ano II, vol. 8, Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de Lisboa: Lisboa, 2013, p. 8859-8890. ISSN: 2182-7567. VEIGA, Fábio da Silva; SILVA, Érica Guerra; BANDEIRA, Gonçalo S. Mello. “A hipótese integradora da governança corporativa e da responsabilidade social corporativa sob o enfoque dos direitos humanos”, in: Direito e Justiça – Aspectos atuais e problemáticos, Tomo III, Direito Privado, Curitiba/Porto: Juruá, 2015, p. 85-102.