La (des)protección de la propia identidad religiosa en la jurisprudencia de Estrasburgo
The (Un)protection of individual religious identity in the Strasbourg Case Law



Downloads per month over past year

Martínez-Torrón, Javier (2012) La (des)protección de la propia identidad religiosa en la jurisprudencia de Estrasburgo. Oxford Journal of Law and Religion, 1 (2). pp. 363-385. ISSN ISSN 2047-0770

[thumbnail of J Martinez-Torron - Unprotection religious identity OJLR 2012.pdf]

Official URL:

Resumen (otros idiomas)

Despite the many positive aspects of the European Court of Strasbourg’s case law on religious freedom, the Court has not provided an adequate protection of individual religious or moral identity, especially when it is expressed in particular actions in ordinary life, beyond traditional expressions of religiosity such as rites or preaching. Two main factors have contributed to this. One is the old European Commission of Human Rights’s doctrine stating that ‘neutral’ laws of general applicability did not constitute an interference with the rights protected by Article 9 ECHR, even in cases of clear conflict with the individual’s moral obligations; the Court has not explicitly accepted this doctrine but seems to have used it on some occasions. The other factor is a peculiar understanding of the ‘neutrality’ of the public sphere as implying or requiring the exclusion of the visibility of religion, which has served to justify national policies banning the wearing of religious garments or clothing. Significantly, most cases of this nature decided by the European Court involve situations related to the educational environment. However, some recent decisions of the Strasbourg Court (Ahmet Arslan, Lautsi GC, Bayatyan) might be expressive of a change in the Court’s jurisprudence.

Item Type:Article
Subjects:Social sciences > Law > Ecclesiastical law
Social sciences > Law > Jurisprudence
ID Code:56222
Deposited On:15 Jul 2019 08:37
Last Modified:05 Apr 2022 09:01

Origin of downloads

Repository Staff Only: item control page