Inconsistencies between chemistry-climate models and observed lower stratospheric ozone trends since 1998


Downloads per month over past year




Downloads per month over past year

Ball, William T. and Chiodo, Gabriel and Ábalos Álvarez, Marta and Alsing, Justin and Stenke, Andrea (2020) Inconsistencies between chemistry-climate models and observed lower stratospheric ozone trends since 1998. Atmospheric chemistry and physics, 20 (16). pp. 9737-9752. ISSN 1680-7316

[thumbnail of abalos04libre+CC.pdf]
Creative Commons Attribution.


Official URL:


The stratospheric ozone layer shields surface life from harmful ultraviolet radiation. Following the Montreal Protocol ban on long-lived ozone-depleting substances (ODSs), rapid depletion of total column ozone (TCO) ceased in the late 1990s, and ozone above 32 km is now clearly recovering. However, there is still no confirmation of TCO recovery, and evidence has emerged that ongoing quasiglobal (60◦ S–60◦ N) lower stratospheric ozone decreases may be responsible, dominated by low latitudes (30◦ S– 30◦ N). Chemistry–climate models (CCMs) used to project future changes predict that lower stratospheric ozone will decrease in the tropics by 2100 but not at mid-latitudes (30–60◦ ). Here, we show that CCMs display an ozone decline similar to that observed in the tropics over 1998–2016, likely driven by an increase in tropical upwelling. On the other hand, mid-latitude lower stratospheric ozone is observed to decrease, while CCMs that specify real-world historical meteorological fields instead show an increase up to present day. However, these cannot be used to simulate future changes; we demonstrate here that free-running CCMs used for projections also show increases. Despite opposing lower stratospheric ozone changes, which should induce opposite temperature trends, CCMs and observed temperature trends agree; we demonstrate that opposing model– observation stratospheric water vapour (SWV) trends, and their associated radiative effects, explain why temperature changes agree in spite of opposing ozone trends. We provide new evidence that the observed mid-latitude trends can be explained by enhanced mixing between the tropics and extratropics. We further show that the temperature trends are consistent with the observed mid-latitude ozone decrease. Together, our results suggest that large-scale circulation changes expected in the future from increased greenhouse gases (GHGs) may now already be underway but that most CCMs do not simulate mid-latitude ozone layer changes well. However, it is important to emphasise that the periods considered here are short, and internal variability that is both intrinsic to each CCM and different to observed historical variability is not well-characterised and can influence trend estimates. Nevertheless, the reason CCMs do not exhibit the observed changes needs to be identified to allow models to be improved in order to build confidence in future projections of the ozone layer.

Item Type:Article
Additional Information:

© Author(s) 2020. This research has been supported by the Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (grant no. 200020_182239) and the Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (grant no. 200020_163206). William T. Ball was partly funded by SNSF projects 200020_163206 (SIMA) and 200020_182239 (POLE). Gabriel Chiodo is funded by SNSF Ambizione grant PZ00P2- 180043.

Uncontrolled Keywords:Brewer-Dobson circulation; Water-vapor; Return dates; Sensitivity; Recovery; 21st-century; Emergence; Transport; Decline
Subjects:Sciences > Physics > Atmospheric physics
ID Code:62604
Deposited On:20 Oct 2020 09:41
Last Modified:20 Oct 2020 09:41

Origin of downloads

Repository Staff Only: item control page