Anti-Luminous Mental States: Logical, Psychological and Epistemic Problems



Downloads per month over past year

González Castán, Óscar L. (2021) Anti-Luminous Mental States: Logical, Psychological and Epistemic Problems. Acta Analytica . ISSN 0353-5150

[thumbnail of González-Castán2021_Article_Anti-LuminousMentalStatesLogic.pdf]
Creative Commons Attribution.


Official URL:


In this paper I shall argue that Tim Williamson’s argument for the anti-luminosity of many mental states faces difficult logical, psychological and epistemological problems. From a logical point of view, his argument is correct. However, the contrary argument that says that the anti-luminosity thesis does not necessarily follow from it is also correct. This opens a sceptical scenario. Hence, if Williamson wants to convince us that we should rationally prefer his argument rather than the other, he needs to add considerations that are not merely logical. These are psychological and epistemological in nature. However, none of these considerations is convincing.

Item Type:Article
Additional Information:

CRUE-CSIC (Acuerdos Transformativos 2021)

Uncontrolled Keywords:Mental states, Scepticism, Antinomy, Psychophysical covariations, Partial sensitivity, Meta-knowledge
Subjects:Humanities > Philosophy > Philosophy of mind
Humanities > Philosophy > Logic
ID Code:69598
Deposited On:17 Jan 2022 10:09
Last Modified:18 Feb 2022 09:38

Origin of downloads

Repository Staff Only: item control page