Lenin and the national question. Beyond essentialism and constructionism

Impacto

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Castién Maestro, Juan Ignacio (2016) Lenin and the national question. Beyond essentialism and constructionism. Nómadas. Critical Journal of Social and Juridical Sciences, 49 . ISSN 1578-6730

[thumbnail of 53536-Texto del artículo-101688-2-10-20160926.pdf]
Preview
PDF
Creative Commons Attribution.

125kB

Official URL: https://doi.org/10.5209/NOMA.53536




Abstract

Lenin's analysis of the 'national question' shows numerous virtualities from a theoretical and political perspective. We are going to examine some of the theoretical conceptions which seem to underlie his view on the national question. In our opinion, these conceptions are a commendable work since they represent an alternative to the dilemma of essentialism and constructivism through which the social contemporary thinking has often fluctuated. Whereas essentialism tends to consider the national fact as a reality by nature and since time immemorial, constructionist approaches like those of Benedict Anderson and Ernest Gellner have insisted on its relatively recent political construction nature. Despite its unquestionable merits, this approach has often fallen into an excessively artificial perspective. According to it, the fabrication of any national identity would be possible with the appropriate skills to do so. Somehow, while essentialism refers to a metaphysical and substantivist, antidialectical approach, constructivism is very reminiscent of the old subjective idealism which believed that reality could be recreated by the individuals with almost complete liberty. For that reason, an approach like that of Lenin which conceives the national question as a long-term historical fact, and only politically manipulable to a very limited extent, could be of great use for materialist theoretical approaches. Some thinkers such as Maxime Rondinson and Pierre Vilar have shown this up.


Item Type:Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:Lenin; Nation; Essentialism; Constructivism
Subjects:Social sciences > Political science
Social sciences > Political science > Political theories
Humanities > Philosophy > Political philosophy
ID Code:70850
Deposited On:02 Mar 2022 11:40
Last Modified:03 Mar 2022 09:07

Origin of downloads

Repository Staff Only: item control page